A client came to me because she wanted to feel confident enough to speak up in meetings at work. She described a pattern she knew well. Someone would ask a question, and she’d spend so much time figuring out what to say that by the time she was ready to answer, her colleagues had moved on. She had something to contribute. She kept missing her chance to say it.
One of the decisions I make as a coach is when to stay with a question and when to suggest we try something. With this client, I needed to understand what she meant by figuring out what to say. Was she still forming an opinion? Did she already have one? From the other side of the meeting table, those two experiences would look exactly the same. For the person sitting in front of me, the difference mattered.
Start with a moment the client can walk you through
We talked through what happened when a colleague asked a question she wanted to answer. As it turned out, she often knew what she thought while there was still plenty of time to contribute. What took time was deciding how to word it. She wanted to sound professional when she spoke in front of her colleagues.
Imagine if we’d spent the session preparing talking points for her next meeting. She could have walked in with three good ideas and still spent the whole discussion polishing the first one. Understanding where she got stuck helped me decide where to take the conversation. She’d used a word I wanted to know more about. What did a professional answer sound like to her?
Get curious about a word that matters
I told her I thought she’d noticed something important. Then I asked what she thought was the worst thing that could happen if she sounded human when she gave her answer. I also asked her to think about the people she heard speaking in those meetings. What was it about the way her colleagues answered questions that sounded more professional than the way she would answer them?
That second question surprised her. When she thought back over the words her colleagues actually used, she couldn’t pick out a difference. They sounded human and natural. She’d heard them speak that way in meeting after meeting and considered them professionals all along. Yet when it was her turn, she felt her own words needed an extra round of editing before anyone else could hear them.
I could have reassured her that it was fine to speak naturally at work. But I don’t sit in those meetings. She does. She could recall how her colleagues expressed their opinions and consider whether she expected any of them to choose their words as carefully as she chose hers. Once she realized how natural their answers sounded to her, giving an answer in her own words felt like less of a risk. That gave us something we could try right there in the session.
Make room to practise during the session
We did a little roleplay. I asked questions as though we were in a meeting, and she practised answering in the words that came naturally to her. We did that a few times. At work, she rarely got to hear how her answer sounded out loud because the conversation kept moving while she was still editing it in her head. With just the two of us there, she could give the answer and hear it for herself.
After we practised, I suggested she make herself a note to take into her meetings. The reminder I had in mind was that she was already a professional and could speak naturally when she answered a question. She made herself that note.
The wording mattered. Imagine glancing down at Speak up! while you’re already trying to decide whether your answer sounds professional enough (thank you, note, I’m working on it). Remembering that she was a professional gave her a reason to trust her own words. I also wanted to give her a way to use those words before she got caught up in trying to get them right.
Suggest a next step that fits what you’ve learned
I suggested she try being the first person to answer a question in her next few meetings, and she agreed to give it a try. That might sound like a big ask for someone who wanted to feel more confident speaking up. What made me suggest it was what she’d told me about those first few seconds. Often, she knew what she wanted to say. It was when she started checking whether it sounded professional enough that she’d get caught up in the wording. Answering first gave her a chance to say what she was thinking before that worry had time to build.
That’s the part of this session you can use with other clients. The suggestion came from paying attention to a moment she knew well and understanding what made it difficult. You can follow that same process with a client who brings you an entirely different problem.
How to try this in your own practice
Suppose a client tells you they’d love to spend part of Sunday afternoon painting, but somehow they always end up doing housework instead. Here’s how you could work through that with them.
Start with one specific moment. Ask, “Can you walk me through what happened last Sunday when you wanted to paint?” Maybe they tell you they took out their sketchbook, saw the breakfast dishes on the table, and decided to tidy up first. By the time they finished cleaning the kitchen, they had to start supper. Now you have a moment you can explore together. What happened when they saw those dishes?
Get curious about what that moment meant to them. You might ask, “How much tidying did you have in mind when you put the sketchbook down?” Maybe all they wanted was a clear spot at the table. Or maybe they tell you, “I’d feel guilty sitting there painting while there was still work to do.” That answer changes what you might suggest. Helping them find another spot to paint would solve the space problem. They could take that guilt with them to any room in the house.
Practise the part they find difficult. If guilt is what gets in the way, invite them to picture last Sunday again. The sketchbook is in their hand, the dishes are on the table, and they have half an hour they’d like to spend painting. Ask, “What would you feel comfortable leaving until later?” Give them room to work through the decision. Maybe they’d be happy to stack the dishes at one end of the table and paint at the other. Let them talk through what it would feel like to sit down and open the sketchbook with the dishes still in sight. That’s the part worth practising.
Agree on one thing they’re willing to try. You could say, “You mentioned you’d feel okay about leaving the dishes until you start supper. Would you like to try that next Sunday and see how it feels?” They get to decide whether that fits or whether they’d change something. If they agree, they know what to do when they get to the table, right down to where they can put the dishes.
Before you offer a suggestion, ask yourself, What did I hear from this client that makes this worth trying? In the painting example, the client already had time set aside. What they needed help with was deciding that the dishes could wait. You only learn that if you stay curious for a moment after they tell you they’d like more time to paint.
Looking for ideas for your next coaching session?
Sometimes a client says something you want to explore, and you’d love a little help figuring out what to ask next. That’s why I created the Coach’s Toolkits. Each one focuses on a specific client goal, with questions you can draw on, worksheets you can use together, and guidance on when each might be useful.
About the author
Michelle Arseneault is a certified life coach, instructional designer, and the creator of Intendify Your Life. She’s curious about the little things people say in passing that turn out to be worth another question. In her articles for coaches, she shares what she notices in her sessions, why she asks the questions she does, and how she decides what to suggest next. Her coaching guides and worksheets give other coaches a place to start when they’re figuring out what might help the person sitting across from them.